Padres vs Cubs
The Padres vs Cubs 2025 season gave us one of the more compelling NL rivalries to watch unfold. San Diego and Chicago met nine times total — six during the regular season and three more when the stakes were highest in the Wild Card Series. When the dust settled, the Cubs had claimed the playoff round 2–1, snapping a lengthy drought that stretched back to their 2017 postseason run.
But playoff outcomes only tell part of the story. The real picture lives in the numbers — batting averages, exit velocities, bullpen ERAs, and the kind of clutch moments that define a rivalry. Here’s the full breakdown of every key stat from these nine games.
2025 Season Series: Quick Overview
Before diving into individual performances, here’s the big-picture summary:
- Regular season split: 3–3 (each team won their home series)
- Postseason result: Cubs advance, 2–1 (NL Wild Card Series)
- Total regular-season runs: Padres 25, Cubs 25 — a perfect draw
- Wild Card attendance: 40,000+ at Wrigley Field for Game 3
- Cubs’ overall record vs. San Diego in 2025: 5–4
The run differential being exactly even through six regular-season games tells you everything about how closely matched these teams were. The playoffs, however, revealed the difference-maker: bullpen depth.
Complete Batting Stats — All Nine Games
| Player | Team | G | AB | R | H | HR | RBI | AVG | OPS |
| Luis Arraez | SD | 6 | 26 | 4 | 11 | 1 | 2 | .423 | 1.098 |
| Nico Hoerner | CHC | 6 | 24 | 5 | 10 | 0 | 4 | .417 | 1.023 |
| Michael Busch | CHC | 3 | 10 | 1 | 4 | 1 | 1 | .400 | 1.200 |
| Seiya Suzuki | CHC | 3 | 11 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 1 | .273 | .965 |
| Fernando Tatis Jr. | SD | 8 | 29 | 7 | 7 | 2 | 7 | .241 | .793 |
| Xander Bogaerts | SD | 8 | 28 | 2 | 6 | 0 | 1 | .214 | .536 |
| Manny Machado | SD | 8 | 29 | 4 | 6 | 2 | 4 | .207 | .690 |
| Jackson Merrill | SD | 8 | 27 | 4 | 5 | 2 | 3 | .185 | .682 |
Stats compiled across the full regular season series and Wild Card round.
Luis Arraez: The Contact Machine the Cubs Couldn’t Figure Out
There’s consistent, and then there’s .423-against-a-playoff-caliber-staff consistent. Luis Arraez landed squarely in the second category.
Across six regular-season games, Arraez collected 11 hits in 26 at-bats. He added a home run — rare for a hitter whose entire identity is making contact — along with two doubles. His 1.098 OPS against Chicago pitching wasn’t a fluke. Arraez made pitchers pay for anything even slightly off the corners, fouling off borderline offerings until he got something to handle.
Seven of those 11 hits came at Petco Park, suggesting home comfort played a role, but the overall number is still exceptional. For fantasy baseball purposes, Arraez becomes an automatic start whenever these two teams meet.
Nico Hoerner: Chicago’s Quietly Excellent Table-Setter
Hoerner doesn’t generate the highlight-reel attention of some Cubs hitters, but his .417 average and 1.023 OPS against San Diego speak for themselves. He hit 10-for-24 in the regular season, drove in four runs, and added a triple that showed surprising gap power for a contact-first shortstop.
Six of those hits came at Wrigley Field, reinforcing the home-field advantage trend that ran through both teams’ offensive numbers this series. Hoerner’s plate discipline — he rarely expanded the zone — gave Chicago a consistent leadoff threat who made life difficult on Padres vs Cubs pitching from the first pitch of the game.
Fernando Tatis Jr.: Power When It Mattered, Inconsistency in Between
Tatis is a contradiction in these stats. Seven RBIs in eight total matchups is genuinely impressive production. Both home runs came in one April 14 game at Petco Park, where he put on a two-homer performance against Cubs pitching that briefly made him look untouchable.
The .241 average tells the other side of the story. Tatis swung through more than he usually does against Chicago’s pitching mix, and his postseason numbers dipped from his regular-season highs. That said, his presence in the lineup forced Chicago pitchers into constant strategic decisions — walk him and pitch to Machado, or attack him and risk the damage.
His defense added another layer in Game 2: a jumping catch in right field that ended the eighth inning and preserved a shutout lead. Tatis as a two-way game-changer, even in an inconsistent series, remains exactly who he was always supposed to be.
Manny Machado: Regular Season Struggles, Playoff Revenge
For a player of Machado’s quality, the regular-season stats (.207 average, .690 OPS) are brutal. Against Chicago’s rotation, he couldn’t quite find his timing through six games, going 6-for-29 with most of his production bunched into a couple of outings.
Then the playoffs arrived.
In Game 2 of the Wild Card Series, Machado crushed a two-run homer off Shota Imanaga that traveled 404 feet into the Wrigley Field left-field bleachers, giving San Diego a 3–0 lead. His exit velocity on the swing hit 104.4 mph. That is a message, not just a home run.
He added four total RBIs in the postseason and capped it off with a defensive gem in the same game: an off-balance throw from third base that beat the runner by a full step and preserved the shutout. Veterans tend to elevate in October, and Machado’s transformation from struggling regular-season hitter to playoff force was one of the defining storylines of this series.
The Cubs’ Postseason Hitters: Suzuki, Kelly, and Busch Step Up
Seiya Suzuki’s Game 1 home run changed the entire complexion of the series. His 424-foot blast to left-center — the longest home run of the entire playoff round — tied the score at 1–1 and shifted momentum back to the Cubs. It was the fifth consecutive game Suzuki had gone deep, dating back to the final days of the regular season.
Carson Kelly followed Suzuki’s bomb with one of his own, making it back-to-back home runs. It was the first time Chicago had accomplished consecutive postseason homers since 2016. Kelly’s regular-season production in this series was modest (three hits overall, four strikeouts in the playoffs), but that one moment may have been the turning point that swung Game 1.
Michael Busch played a limited role but delivered when given opportunities. His four hits in 10 at-bats (.400 average) and a solo homer in Game 3 gave Chicago timely production from a left-handed bat off the bench.
Pitching Breakdown: Ace Performances and Bullpen Battles
The Starters
Matthew Boyd was arguably the most dominant starter in any single outing between these teams. His April 5 performance — six shutout innings, one walk, five strikeouts — set a tone for how effective Chicago’s rotation could be against San Diego’s lineup when executing their plan.
Boyd returned in Game 1 of the Wild Card Series and helped limit the Padres vs Cubs again, continuing a strong run against this particular opponent.
Dylan Cease answered with his own playoff gem in Game 2. Three and two-thirds scoreless innings, five strikeouts, and a fastball that repeatedly touched triple digits. His slider kept Cubs hitters consistently off-balance, generating weak contact and whiffs in equal measure. The performance felt like Cease reclaiming his ace identity after a regular season with mixed results.
Nick Pivetta started Game 1 and looked sharp early — retiring 11 consecutive batters before Suzuki’s homer halted the streak. Nine strikeouts in five innings is a strong line, but the bullpen couldn’t protect the lead after he exited.
Jameson Taillon was the unsung hero of the series in Game 3. Four shutout innings on efficient pitches, two hits allowed, and a steady stream of weak contact that handed the Cubs’ bullpen a clean situation to close out.
The Bullpen Was the Difference
This is where Chicago genuinely separated itself from San Diego.
Mason Miller made one of the most memorable playoff debuts in recent memory. He struck out the first eight batters he faced in the postseason — an MLB record for a reliever making his playoff debut. He also threw the hardest pitch of the entire postseason: a 104.5 mph fastball that no tracking system had recorded harder in October since pitch data collection began in 2008.
Despite that performance, Miller was ultimately on the losing side as the Cubs advanced. But his emergence as a legitimate late-inning weapon is the most significant development for the Padres coming out of this series.
Adrián Morejón covered 2⅓ innings in Game 2, navigating a bases-loaded situation and stranding two runners in the fourth to bridge the gap to Miller. Robert Suarez closed out Game 2 with a perfect ninth — two strikeouts while protecting a three-run lead.
On the Chicago side, their bullpen was collective and surgical. Cubs relievers threw four innings of scoreless ball in Game 1, the key stretch that held a close lead. Andrew Kittredge earned the series-clinching save in Game 3, retiring Jake Cronenworth and Freddy Fermin to end San Diego’s season.
The Cubs didn’t lean on one dominant arm the way the Padres leaned on Miller. They had depth, and in a short series, depth beats dominance.
Defense: Three Plays That Shaped the Series
Three defensive moments stood out across the nine games:
Fernando Tatis Jr., Game 2, eighth inning — A leaping catch in right field that looked physically impossible for a split second before he snagged it cleanly. The play ended the inning and preserved a shutout.
Manny Machado, Game 2 — The off-balance throw that’s already being replayed on highlight compilations. Coming across his body from third base, Machado’s arm strength and footwork beat the runner by a step. It’s the kind of play that defensive metrics can’t fully quantify.
Pete Crow-Armstrong, Game 1 — Crow-Armstrong’s range in center field produced several highlight moments in Games 2 and 3, but he offset some of that with a throwing error in Game 1 that allowed Xander Bogaerts to reach third base. He recovered well across the series, but the miscue was a reminder that elite defenders can still cost teams in tight playoff games.
Home Field Advantage: The Numbers Back It Up
The trend was consistent throughout this series. The home team won two of three games in both April series at Wrigley Field and Petco Park. In the playoffs, Wrigley’s crowd of 40,000-plus for Game 3 created an atmosphere that clearly affected visiting hitters.
Arraez grabbed seven of his 11 hits at home. Hoerner collected six of his 10 at Wrigley. These aren’t coincidences — they reflect how crowd energy and familiar surroundings influence hitter comfort in regular-season situations. In October, that advantage amplifies further.
Who Struggled: The Underperformers
Not every star delivered.
Xander Bogaerts went 6-for-28 against Chicago pitching — a .214 average from a player expected to anchor the San Diego middle of the order. He struck out three times in the playoff series alone and failed to drive in a single run across all nine games. Bogaerts has historically been a strong playoff performer, making this particular series one he’ll want to revisit.
Jackson Merrill had an even tougher time, hitting .185 over eight games with a .682 OPS. His two home runs kept him from being a complete liability, but the overall production from a player San Diego expects more from was disappointing.
Carson Kelly beyond his Game 1 home run was largely invisible. Three total hits in the series, four strikeouts in the playoffs, and a tendency to chase pitches off the plate characterised a tough overall run despite that one crucial moment.
Key Takeaways From These Nine Games
Arraez is untouchable in this matchup. A .423 average isn’t a hot streak against a bad team — it’s a genuine skill-set mismatch. Chicago pitchers never found a consistent way to retire him.
Miller is the most electric arm in the game right now. Eight straight strikeouts and a 104.5 mph fastball as a playoff rookie. That sentence doesn’t need further context.
Chicago’s depth won the series. Suzuki’s homer, Kelly’s follow-up blast, Taillon’s quiet Game 3, Kittredge’s clutch save — no single Cubs player was the hero, which is exactly how playoff series get won.
San Diego’s star-driven model has a ceiling. When Tatis and Machado struggle at the same time, the Padres lack the depth to compensate. The Cubs’ system produced contributions from players four and five deep in the roster. That’s the organizational difference that cost San Diego this October.
FAQs
Who led all hitters in the 2025 Padres-Cubs matchups?
Luis Arraez. His 11 hits in 26 at-bats produced a .423 average and 1.098 OPS — the best single-series performance by any batter from either team.
What was Mason Miller’s fastest pitch in the series?
Miller hit 104.5 mph in Game 2 of the Wild Card Series — officially the hardest pitch thrown in October since MLB began tracking pitch velocity.
How many home runs did Tatis Jr. hit against Chicago?
Two, both in the same regular-season game on April 14 at Petco Park.
Which starting pitcher was most dominant against San Diego?
Matthew Boyd’s April 5 outing stands out: six shutout innings, one walk, five strikeouts. He also contributed in the postseason.
Who hit the longest home run of the playoff series?
Seiya Suzuki, at 424 feet, Game 1, Wrigley Field. The shot went to left-center and tied the game at 1–1.
What was the final record between these teams in 2025?
The Cubs went 5–4 overall against San Diego — three regular-season wins plus the 2–1 Wild Card Series victory.
Final Verdict
This rivalry has everything. Star power on both sides, contrasting organizational philosophies, and a postseason outcome that genuinely surprised no one who watched the bullpens closely. The Cubs’ 5–4 edge in 2025 came down to Wrigley’s crowd, relief pitcher depth, and timely contributions from players who weren’t supposed to be heroes.
San Diego has the names. Chicago has the system. When those two things collide in a short series, the system tends to win.
Every future meeting between these franchises will carry weight. Keep watching.
About the Author
